I was listening to comedian Rush Limbaugh again on Tuesday. He was advancing his radical consumerism viewpoint by arguing that we’ve got an endless supply of oil to burn. No need to worry about fossil fuels or global warming–buy a big SUV and be happy.
First he pointed to a story on a United Arab Emirates airliner ordering more airplanes as proof that there’s plenty of oil. Why would an Arab country be ordering more aircraft if we we’re running out of oil?
An interesting argument, but one you can just as easily turn on its head. Perhaps the company realizes that with tight oil supplies, it will be uniquely positioned to turn a profit if it has better local access to fuel than international competitors. Moreover, high energy prices would be a boon to Arab economies (at least in the short term), generating more passenger growth, and account for the “highly favourable home and regional market dynamics” rationale cited by the airline.
Limbaugh went on to say this:
Probably, you know, the conventional wisdom, “We’re running out of oil supplies! Global warming,” blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. That stuff is here for a reason. It’s part of creation. God intended it to be used as we’re using it, and we’re using it, and there’s tons of it out there.
Putting aside the question of whether or not God created the oil for us to use, how does that claim address scarcity? God also created water and food, and we’ve got plenty of examples of societies running short of those resources. Just because God may have created something does mean we have infinite supply to consume. God has never guaranteed $3/gallon gasoline. Nature has its limits, whether Limbaugh wants to recognize them or not.